Maud Newton recently mentioned her interest in further exploring the work of Clive James. We're immoderate in our James enthusiasm, and so we'd like to direct one and all to this handy compendium of James links, courtesy his own website. (This review of the Kingsley Amis bio for the TLS is representative.) It makes for wildly entertaining reading.
In his time, Professor Carey had called Lucky Jim a funny book; or had at least implied that it was, by saying that its author's autobiography, Memoirs, was his funniest book since the one that made his name. Professor Carey, a true wit in his own right, is well aware that a funny book is always an achievement. But in his review of this biography — a review that amounted to placing a corpse under arrest and charging it with a misspent life — no achievements were mentioned. At least that omission left room for a scrupulous and influential critic to remind himself, at some future time, that there might be beginners listening, and that the starting point of a critical essay should therefore always be the subject's gifts, and not his crimes. If the subject did not possess the first, there would be no point discussing the second. One lesser critic managed to do even worse than not mention Amis's work. He presumed, in the yellow light of all this sulphurous information about the author's moral transgressions, to reassess the work, pointing out that Amis's poetry, in particular, was a glacial reflection of his heartless attitude towards women.
We also highly recommend his prior collection, As of This Writing. Tasty stuff, if you can find it.
About a week ago, someone who appears to be Jonathan Raban turned up in my comments box to expand on his dislike of Clive James. The link on my name should go to the right post, if that's of interest.
Posted by: Jasper Milvain | March 29, 2007 at 03:56 AM
Both James and (Robert) Hughes get the ocassional sniffy knock (re: Raban) for mixing too much testAUSterone in with their erudition, but I'd rather read either than most (on certain topics). James's Amis bio review came at a time when every other reviewer seemed to be doing a Pilgrim reading of the Amis legend (women; kaffir-flogging)and it was a welcome change...for being not only clever but mature.
Posted by: Steven Augustine | March 30, 2007 at 08:34 AM